We will help you get your newsletter off to the races!
Share
Acquiring LI subscribers, but crippled by reach? Here’s what to expect
Published 14 days ago • 3 min read
👋 Hi Reader,
I am a LinkedIn nut.
I take all the arguments about LinkedIn being all cringe, AI-slop, broetry memes, and I raise you this: it is still the only social network I know, which insists on you showing up as your true self, not just a random handle ladiesman217.
(10 points to you, if you caught the movie reference)
So it follows that I spend an inordinate amount of time and effort understanding how the LinkedIn algo behaves. Which is when I realized that huge audience followership on LinkedIn has lately not been proportional to massive engagement.
For the longest time, big audiences on Twitter and Instagram led to massive initial reach and engagement. Tiktok subverted that trend to happen entirely on the strength of its content-trained algorithm without a big followership (read Eugene Wei’’s 2021 deep dive essay on the Tiktok algorithm for context)
Eugene Wei's essay on the Tiktok algorithm in 2021
Having said that, for the longest time, LinkedIn felt like an old friend: you could post something into the feed, and your hype group would show up with “great posts” and “100% agree” (I am typing all this with as best a straight face as I can manage, don’t report me to LinkedIn Lunatics)
But come 2025, and LinkedIn feels like a ghost town. Reach has plummeted by almost 60-70%, and AI commenting has reached new lows with people sending platitudes written by ChatGPT. I can no longer be assured that having an audience bigger than 5k is any assurance of getting decent reach.
So I decided to spend some time investigating, and I found 2 resources worth the long weekend read, so I am sharing with you.
The Shield Index from the Shield team
Andreas Jonsson and his team have been building Shield for a few years now, and they understand LinkedIn like no other product team does. I had been a Shield user from its early days, and I trust his read on the platform.
They spend quite a bit of time and effort deciphering the algo every month on The Shield Index, a monthly performance briefing where they tell you what they tested and learnt. It’s an email-only waitlist, and they share plain actionable advice for anyone looking to build their audience on LinkedIn.
For example, this table from their Nov 2025 briefing is itself worth the price of admission. It tells you what reach to realistically expect in recent months, given the current followership you have.
The Shield Index Nov 2025 report preview
If you ask me, I would sign up immediately.
The Ocean Labs Report on what to expect in 2026
This report aggregates insights across several reputable sources, including Richard van der Blom’s analysis. Richard himself is an eminent authority in the LinkedIn space. This report combines his insights with AuthoredUp research (another well-known LI growth platform like Shield), so you get LinkedIn growth tactics that you could apply TODAY.
What’s not to like?
Sabin Selimi's post about the Ocean Labs Report
I hope these two resources singularly help you change the way you repurpose your newsletter content on LinkedIn and grow your email list.
Still have questions on LinkedIn? You know I am here to help.
Let me know by hitting ‘Reply’ on this email, or send a note to marketing@letterstack.co, and I would be happy to be a sounding board for your LinkedIn growth process.
No questions? I wish you a great downtime and happy holidays to you and your families! See you next week.
This newsletter is sponsored by The Alien Design
Looking for a partner to bring your digital product ideas to life? Alien specializes in product design, web design, and Webflow development. Alien helps businesses build visually appealing digital experiences that drive results. From concept to launch, Alien focus on delivering solutions that fit your brand and meet your business goals.
Want to get featured as the next sponsor on LetterStack? Reach out to us on marketing@letterstack.co!
Make Sure You Get Our Emails!
To ensure our emails land in your main inbox, follow these easy steps:
Find this email in your Promotions tab.
Drag it to the Primary tab.
When Gmail asks, click "Yes" to get our future emails in your main inbox.
You can also add us to your contacts to stay updated!
We Value Your Feedback
Your feedback means the world to us! Just hit reply and share your thoughts on this edition - we're always looking to improve. You could also reach out to us on marketing@letterstack.co.
Cheers,
Renga from LetterStack
Was this email forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up here to get content like this directly in your inbox!
👋 Hi Reader, Ryan Carr is an awesome guy. I happened to meet him last February in Austin, where I got to express my gratitude for the content he had been putting on Youtube. Along with Matt McGarry, he has created a helpful compilation of videos on how newsletter creators should think about their content strategy. The reason I bring up Ryan today, is he also frequently puts together amazing AI-centric tutorials. One of them happens to be creating entire newsletter content pieces with Claude -...
👋 Hi Reader, You know I am a sucker for seeing local businesses thrive. I never leave any stone unturned to cover helpful resources at the intersection of local businesses and newsletters. Since we are heading into downtime for the holiday season, I figure some of you are preparing hard and committing yourself to launch a local newsletter or media brand in 2026. If that’s a 'hell yes', you are in luck. I compiled 3 digital stocking stuffers from the best experienced local newsletter creators,...
👋 Hi Reader, Seems like Substack newsletter creators cannot catch a break. The Substack platform has been rapidly making changes in 2025, and not of the good kind. First came paid subscriptions through the iOS app cutting paid earnings dramatically (we covered the paid subscription math in this LetterStack issue) Then came the shaky content moderation stance with a lot of questionable (absent?) decisions being made around moderating newsletters promoting hate speech. If you are curious about...